TCPA

58 “Stop” Requests Ignored: Federal Judge Lets Consumer’s Robocall and Text Lawsuit Against Business Funder Move Forward

Man with fingers in his ears, ignoring requests to stop calling and texting

By Ginsburg Law Group | TCPA & Robocall Rights

Picture replying “STOP” to a sales text. Then doing it again. And again. Now picture doing it 58 times and still getting calls and texts. According to a lawsuit pending in federal court in Idaho, that is what happened to one consumer. A federal judge has now refused to throw his case out.

If you have ever felt like a company simply refuses to hear you, this case is worth knowing about.

What the consumer says happened

In Vandersloot v. ATYG, LLC, No. 4:26-cv-00275 (D. Idaho), the plaintiff says his cell phone number was on the National Do Not Call Registry. Even so, he alleges he received more than 130 calls and texts pitching business funding. The messages came under the name “Steady Capital Solution,” which he alleges is a name the defendant used. He says he asked the company to stop 58 separate times, and the contacts kept coming.

He sued under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA), the federal law that limits telemarketing calls, robocalls and automated texts. These are allegations; the company has not been found liable for anything.

The company’s defense, and why the court rejected it

Instead of answering the complaint, the funding company asked the court to dismiss the case. It raised just about every argument available:

  • “It wasn’t us.” The company argued the complaint didn’t show that it sent the messages, either directly or through someone acting for it. Because the consumer tied the “Steady Capital Solution” name to the defendant, the court found that was enough at this early stage.
  • “The complaint is a mess.” The company called it an improper “shotgun” pleading. The court found the complaint perfectly understandable.
  • “These weren’t sales calls.” The company argued the consumer didn’t rule out an existing business relationship. But under FCC rules, when you tell a seller to stop calling, that request ends any business relationship for telemarketing purposes, even if you still do business with them. After 58 requests, that argument went nowhere.
  • “Texts aren’t calls.” Some courts have recently accepted this argument (more on that below). It did not succeed here.
  • “We didn’t use an autodialer.” This is often a defendant’s strongest argument, because courts in the Ninth Circuit, which includes Idaho, read the definition of an “automatic telephone dialing system” narrowly. Even so, the court let the claim go forward.
  • “Nothing here was willful.” The consumer’s 58 ignored requests made that a hard sell. If willfulness is proven, the TCPA lets the court triple the damages.

The result: the motion to dismiss was denied, and the case moves forward.

Why this matters to you

Your “STOP” is supposed to mean stop. Federal rules require businesses to honor a request to revoke consent made in any reasonable way, within a reasonable time of no more than 10 business days. Telemarketers must also keep their own internal do-not-call lists and honor them. A company that keeps texting after you’ve said no for the 2nd, 10th or 58th time is creating evidence against itself.

Ignored requests can add up to real money. The TCPA allows consumers to recover $500 per violating call or text, and up to $1,500 per call or text when the violation is willful or knowing. With more than 130 contacts at issue, the potential exposure in a case like this is significant.

Being a business owner doesn’t take away your rights. Merchant cash advance and business-funding companies often target small business owners on their personal cell phones. If you use your cell phone mainly as a personal phone, those sales calls and texts may still be covered by the TCPA. If you have already taken a cash advance and are dealing with aggressive collection, read our guide on how merchant cash advance collection tactics can cripple a small business.

The “texts aren’t calls” fight is real. Several federal courts have recently held that a text message isn’t a “telephone call” under the do-not-call part of the TCPA. We explained why that trend worries us in Courts Keep Saying Texts Aren’t “Calls.” Consumers Are the Ones Paying for It. This case shows that the outcome still depends on the court and the facts, so don’t assume you have no claim just because the messages were texts.

What to do if a company won’t stop calling or texting

  • Say stop clearly, and keep proof. Reply STOP (or QUIT, END, CANCEL or UNSUBSCRIBE) to texts. On calls, tell the caller to put you on their do-not-call list. Screenshot every reply.
  • Keep a log. Write down the date, time, number, company name and what was said for every call. Save voicemails.
  • Register your number at donotcall.gov if you haven’t already. Registration is free and doesn’t expire.
  • Note every name the company uses. Many sellers text under trade names or through “partners.” Like the “Steady Capital Solution” name in this case, those names can be traced back to the real company.
  • Don’t engage with the pitch. Asking a follow-up question can give the company an argument that you invited more contact. We covered this trap in Told a Car Dealer to STOP Texting?.
  • Know the new opt-out rules. New FCC rules on how you opt out of robocalls and robotexts take effect November 25, 2026. Our guide explains how to make sure your opt-out counts.

The bottom line

Companies that ignore consumers’ requests to stop are counting on people giving up. When you document every ignored “STOP,” you build the evidence that makes those companies pay attention.

If you’re getting calls or texts you’ve already asked to stop, or messages to a number on the Do Not Call Registry, contact Ginsburg Law Group for a free case review. We represent consumers in TCPA cases and can tell you whether your calls and texts add up to a claim.

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *