By Ginsburg Law Group, P.C. | Estate Planning & Trust Administration
When families establish irrevocable trusts, they often want to accomplish two goals that can appear contradictory: provide beneficiaries with access to money when they need it while protecting trust assets from unnecessary estate taxes, creditors, and premature distributions.
Two estate-planning tools that can help accomplish these goals are the HEMS distribution standard and the 5-and-5 withdrawal power.
Although they are sometimes used together, these provisions serve different purposes.
A HEMS provision allows distributions for a beneficiary’s health, education, maintenance, and support. A 5-and-5 power gives a beneficiary a limited right to withdraw trust principal, generally up to the greater of $5,000 or 5% of the trust’s value annually, if the trust grants that right.
Understanding the difference is particularly important when a beneficiary also serves as trustee or when children and grandchildren are designated to inherit whatever remains in the trust.
What Is a HEMS Standard?
HEMS stands for:
- Health
- Education
- Maintenance
- Support
A trust using a HEMS standard authorizes the trustee to make distributions for these specified purposes.
For example, a parent may create a trust for an adult child and authorize distributions for the child’s health, education, maintenance, and support.
The trustee may use trust funds for expenses such as medical treatment, tuition, housing, insurance, and other appropriate support needs.
The precise scope depends on the trust language, the beneficiary’s circumstances, and applicable law.
Why Is HEMS Important for Estate Taxes?
Under IRC § 2041(b)(1)(A), a power to consume, invade, or appropriate property for the holder’s own benefit is not treated as a general power of appointment if it is limited by an ascertainable standard relating to health, education, support, or maintenance.
Treasury Regulation § 20.2041-1(c)(2) explains how this exception applies.
This distinction can be extremely important when the beneficiary also serves as trustee.
If a beneficiary-trustee can distribute trust principal to themselves only under a properly drafted HEMS standard, that authority generally does not constitute a general power of appointment merely because the beneficiary holds the distribution power.
Consequently, the trust assets ordinarily are not included in the beneficiary’s taxable estate solely because of that limited power.
However, other estate-inclusion rules may still apply.
What Expenses Can Be Paid Under HEMS?
A properly drafted HEMS provision can provide substantial flexibility.
Health
Depending on the trust’s terms, health-related distributions may include:
- Medical and dental expenses.
- Prescription medications.
- Health insurance.
- Mental health treatment.
- Necessary medical equipment.
- Long-term care expenses.
Education
Education-related distributions may include:
- College and graduate school tuition.
- Vocational training.
- Books and educational supplies.
- Reasonable housing and living expenses associated with education.
- Other qualifying educational expenses.
Maintenance and Support
Maintenance and support may include:
- Mortgage or rent payments.
- Property taxes and insurance.
- Utilities and ordinary living expenses.
- Transportation.
- Food and clothing.
- Expenses reasonably associated with the beneficiary’s accustomed standard of living.
The HEMS standard does not necessarily require the beneficiary to be impoverished before receiving trust distributions.
A trust may authorize support consistent with the beneficiary’s established lifestyle.
However, not every expenditure qualifies merely because the beneficiary wants it.
For example, luxury vacations, expensive gifts, or speculative investments may fall outside a narrowly drafted HEMS standard, depending on the trust’s language and circumstances.
The central question is whether the distribution is authorized by the trust’s ascertainable standard, not whether a future beneficiary considers the expense excessive.
What Is a 5-and-5 Power?
A 5-and-5 power is a limited annual withdrawal right commonly used in estate planning. (For a deeper dive, see The 5-and-5 Power in Estate Planning.)
Under IRC § 2041(b)(2), the lapse of a general power of appointment is generally not treated as a release to the extent the property subject to the lapse does not exceed the greater of:
- $5,000; or
- 5% of the aggregate value of the assets from which the power could be satisfied.
For example, a trust may provide that a beneficiary has the right each year to withdraw the greater of $5,000 or 5% of the trust’s value.
This gives the beneficiary a defined opportunity to access trust principal without requiring a HEMS-related reason.
Unlike a HEMS distribution, a validly exercisable 5-and-5 withdrawal power generally does not require the beneficiary to demonstrate a medical, educational, or support need.
Example: How Much Can a Beneficiary Withdraw?
| Trust value | 5% of value | Annual withdrawal amount |
|---|---|---|
| $80,000 | $4,000 | $5,000 |
| $250,000 | $12,500 | $12,500 |
| $750,000 | $37,500 | $37,500 |
| $2,000,000 | $100,000 | $100,000 |
These examples assume the trust grants an annual withdrawal right measured by the greater of $5,000 or 5% of the relevant trust assets.
The tax statute itself does not automatically give beneficiaries this right. It must be created by the trust document.
How HEMS and 5-and-5 Powers Work Together
A trust can provide both a HEMS distribution standard and a separate 5-and-5 withdrawal power.
For example, a parent may establish an irrevocable trust for an adult daughter.
The trust provides that:
- The daughter may serve as trustee and make distributions to herself for health, education, maintenance, and support.
- The daughter also has an annual right to withdraw up to the greater of $5,000 or 5% of the trust’s value.
- Any remaining trust property passes to her children after her death.
This structure may give the daughter meaningful access to trust assets while limiting the estate-tax consequences of her powers.
The HEMS provision permits distributions for qualifying needs.
The 5-and-5 provision permits an additional limited withdrawal without requiring the daughter to satisfy the HEMS standard.
However, the tax treatment of an unexercised withdrawal power is different from the tax treatment of a HEMS-limited trustee power.
In California, the HEMS limit on a beneficiary-trustee can also apply by default. Under Probate Code § 16081(c), unless the trust clearly indicates a broader power by express reference to that subdivision, a beneficiary serving as trustee may make discretionary distributions to themselves only for health, education, support, or maintenance within the meaning of IRC §§ 2041 and 2514, subject to statutory exceptions.
Does a 5-and-5 Power Cause Estate Tax Inclusion?
This is one of the most important distinctions.
A presently exercisable withdrawal power is generally a general power of appointment to the extent the beneficiary can withdraw trust property for personal use.
Under IRC § 2041, property subject to a general power of appointment held at death may be included in the beneficiary’s gross estate.
The 5-and-5 rule does not provide a blanket exclusion for an unexercised withdrawal power held at death.
Instead, IRC § 2041(b)(2) generally provides favorable treatment for the lapse of a withdrawal power within the statutory threshold.
Example
Suppose a beneficiary has a properly drafted annual withdrawal power over $50,000 of trust principal.
If the power expires during the beneficiary’s lifetime, the lapse may fall within the 5-and-5 exception, depending on the trust value and applicable rules.
However, if the beneficiary dies while the withdrawal power remains exercisable, the property subject to that power may be included in the beneficiary’s gross estate.
This is why careful drafting of the exercise period, lapse provisions, and valuation rules is essential.
A 5-and-5 power is not automatically estate-tax neutral in every circumstance.
What Happens If the Beneficiary Does Not Exercise the 5-and-5 Power?
Many beneficiaries choose not to exercise their annual withdrawal rights.
When a power lapses, the federal tax treatment depends on the amount subject to the lapse.
Under IRC § 2041(b)(2), a lapse within the greater-of-$5,000-or-5% threshold generally is not treated as a release of a general power of appointment for purposes of that provision.
However, if the amount lapsing exceeds the statutory threshold, the excess may be treated as a release, potentially creating estate-tax consequences under IRC § 2041(a)(2).
Gift-tax consequences must also be considered under IRC § 2514.
Some trusts use special lapse provisions, sometimes called hanging powers, to manage the amount of a withdrawal right that expires in a particular year.
These provisions require careful drafting and tax analysis.
Can Grandchildren Challenge a Parent’s Use of HEMS or 5-and-5 Powers?
This issue frequently arises in multigenerational trusts. (We address it in more detail in Can Grandchildren Sue a Parent Over Trust Distributions?)
Suppose a trust provides lifetime benefits to a daughter, with the remaining property passing to her children.
The daughter serves as trustee and has both HEMS distribution authority and an annual 5-and-5 withdrawal right.
Her children believe she is spending too much trust money and reducing their future inheritance.
Can they challenge her decisions?
The answer depends on which authority she is exercising.
HEMS Distributions
If the daughter makes distributions to herself as trustee under the HEMS standard, she must comply with the trust’s terms and applicable fiduciary duties.
Remainder beneficiaries may have grounds to challenge distributions that exceed the HEMS standard or constitute a breach of trust.
However, they generally cannot prevent legitimate support distributions merely because those distributions reduce the amount they may inherit.
5-and-5 Withdrawals
If the daughter exercises a valid personal withdrawal right within the limits established by the trust, she generally does not need to demonstrate that the money is being used for health, education, maintenance, or support.
The right is ordinarily exercisable according to its terms.
Once property has been properly withdrawn and becomes the daughter’s personal property, the remainder beneficiaries generally cannot dictate how she spends it simply because they expected to inherit the remaining trust assets.
They may still dispute whether the withdrawal exceeded the authorized amount or complied with the trust’s procedures.
A personal withdrawal right and a trustee’s discretionary distribution authority are legally distinct.
HEMS vs. 5-and-5 Powers: Key Differences
| Feature | HEMS Standard | 5-and-5 Power |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Permits distributions for defined needs | Permits limited withdrawals |
| Must show qualifying need? | Yes, under applicable standard | Generally no |
| Who exercises authority? | Trustee | Beneficiary holding withdrawal power |
| Annual dollar limit | No fixed statutory dollar cap | Greater of $5,000 or 5% if drafted that way |
| Estate-tax treatment | Generally ascertainable-standard exception | Special lapse exception; active powers may cause inclusion |
| Can remainder beneficiaries challenge? | Potentially, for improper distributions | Generally limited to violations of withdrawal terms or other legal grounds |
| Can trust principal be reduced? | Yes | Yes |
Does HEMS or a 5-and-5 Power Protect Assets From Creditors?
Neither provision automatically guarantees creditor protection.
Spendthrift provisions and applicable state law are important.
For example, California has specific rules concerning creditor access to trust distributions and certain powers held by beneficiaries.
An enforceable spendthrift clause may protect some trust interests, but exceptions and statutory limitations apply. (See Can Creditors Take Your Inheritance?)
A presently exercisable withdrawal power can create different creditor-access concerns from a discretionary HEMS interest.
Similarly, a beneficiary serving as trustee may face additional scrutiny if the trust permits broad self-distributions.
Asset protection should be analyzed separately from federal estate-tax treatment.
What About QTIP Trusts?
HEMS standards and 5-and-5 powers may also appear in trusts designed to qualify for the federal estate-tax marital deduction. (See What Is a QTIP Trust? and Can a QTIP Trust Include 5-and-5 Withdrawal Powers for Both a Surviving Spouse and Children?)
A QTIP trust generally requires the surviving spouse to receive all fiduciary accounting income at least annually.
The trust may also permit principal distributions for the surviving spouse’s HEMS needs.
However, a QTIP trust must satisfy specific requirements under IRC § 2056(b)(7), including restrictions on appointing property to persons other than the surviving spouse during the spouse’s lifetime.
A proposed withdrawal power must therefore be coordinated with the QTIP requirements.
In addition, QTIP property subject to a valid election is generally included in the surviving spouse’s gross estate under IRC § 2044, regardless of whether a HEMS power would otherwise avoid general-power-of-appointment treatment.
Accordingly, the HEMS exception does not eliminate QTIP estate inclusion.
How Should These Powers Be Drafted?
Effective drafting requires more than simply inserting the words “HEMS” or “5-and-5” into a trust.
Important considerations include:
- Clear distribution standards. Specify the permitted purposes and whether other resources available to the beneficiary must be considered.
- Defined withdrawal periods. Explain when the annual withdrawal right begins, how long it remains exercisable, and how it expires.
- Valuation procedures. Establish how the relevant trust assets are valued when calculating the 5% amount.
- Notice requirements. Specify how a beneficiary exercises the withdrawal right.
- Trustee succession. Address who administers the trust if the beneficiary-trustee becomes incapacitated or dies.
- Remainder beneficiary protection. Clarify how legitimate distributions and withdrawals affect the interests of future beneficiaries.
- Tax coordination. Evaluate estate-tax inclusion, gift-tax consequences, generation-skipping transfer taxes, and income-tax treatment.
For some families, an independent trustee may be appropriate for distributions exceeding an ascertainable standard.
The Bottom Line
HEMS standards and 5-and-5 withdrawal powers can provide valuable flexibility in irrevocable trust planning.
A properly drafted HEMS standard can allow a beneficiary who serves as trustee to make distributions for defined needs without automatically creating a general power of appointment.
A 5-and-5 provision can give the beneficiary additional access to trust principal without requiring a qualifying HEMS expense.
However, the two provisions have different legal and tax consequences.
The 5-and-5 rule primarily addresses the lapse of withdrawal powers; it does not guarantee that property subject to an active withdrawal right will be excluded from the beneficiary’s estate.
For multigenerational trusts, these provisions should also be coordinated with trustee duties, remainder beneficiary rights, creditor protection, and the trust creator’s objectives.
The goal is to provide beneficiaries with appropriate financial flexibility while preserving the tax and asset-protection benefits the trust was designed to achieve.
Contact Ginsburg Law Group
Ginsburg Law Group, P.C. assists individuals and families with estate planning, trust administration, and related legal matters.
If you are creating an irrevocable trust, reviewing an existing trust, or considering HEMS and withdrawal provisions for family beneficiaries, our attorneys can help evaluate the available options.
Schedule a consultation or email estates@ginsburglawgroup.com.
Legal Authorities and Resources
- IRC § 2041(b)(1)(A): Ascertainable Standard Exception
- IRC § 2041(b)(2): Lapse of General Power of Appointment
- IRC § 2514: Gift-Tax Treatment of Powers of Appointment
- IRC § 2056(b)(7): Qualified Terminable Interest Property
- IRC § 2044: Estate Inclusion of QTIP Property
- Treasury Regulation § 20.2041-1(c)(2): Ascertainable Standards
- Treasury Regulation § 20.2041-3: Powers Created After October 21, 1942
- California Probate Code §§ 15300–15309: Spendthrift Trust and Creditor Rules
- California Probate Code § 16080 and § 16081: Trustee Discretion
Disclaimer: This article provides general educational information and does not constitute individualized legal or tax advice. Trust distribution powers, withdrawal rights, estate-tax consequences, and creditor protections depend on the trust instrument, applicable law, and individual circumstances. Reading this article does not establish an attorney-client relationship with Ginsburg Law Group, P.C.


