How to Balance Lifetime Financial Security, Inheritance Protection, and Estate Taxes
By Ginsburg Law Group, P.C.
When married couples create an estate plan, they often want to accomplish three goals: provide financial security for the surviving spouse, preserve assets for their children, and protect the inheritance eventually passing to grandchildren.
A Qualified Terminable Interest Property (QTIP) trust can help accomplish these objectives.
But what if the surviving spouse needs more than the trust’s annual income? What if the couple also wants their children to have access to inherited assets without receiving their entire inheritance outright?
One strategy is to combine a QTIP trust with health, education, maintenance, and support (HEMS) distribution provisions and limited annual withdrawal rights commonly called 5-and-5 powers.
Properly structured, these provisions can provide flexibility across multiple generations while preserving important estate-planning benefits.
However, the timing of the withdrawal powers, the identity of the beneficiaries, and the federal tax consequences are critical.
What Is a QTIP Trust?
A QTIP trust is an estate-planning arrangement that allows one spouse to provide lifetime benefits to the surviving spouse while determining who receives the remaining assets after the surviving spouse dies. (For the basics, see What Is a QTIP Trust?)
For example, a husband might establish a QTIP trust providing that:
- His wife receives all trust income during her lifetime.
- The trustee may distribute principal for her health, education, maintenance, and support.
- After her death, the remaining trust assets pass to their children.
- The children’s shares continue in separate trusts for the benefit of future generations.
Under Internal Revenue Code § 2056(b)(7), a properly structured QTIP trust may qualify for the federal estate-tax marital deduction when the required election is made.
Generally, the surviving spouse must be entitled to all fiduciary accounting income, payable at least annually, and no person may have the power to appoint QTIP property to someone other than the surviving spouse during the spouse’s lifetime.
This structure can be particularly valuable in blended families and multigenerational estate plans.
What Is a 5-and-5 Withdrawal Power?
A 5-and-5 power is a trust provision allowing a beneficiary to withdraw a limited amount of trust principal. (More background: The 5-and-5 Power in Estate Planning.)
The commonly used formula is the greater of:
- $5,000 annually; or
- 5% of the applicable trust assets.
For example, if a trust holds $2 million, a properly drafted annual 5-and-5 withdrawal right could allow the beneficiary to withdraw $100,000.
The beneficiary ordinarily does not have to demonstrate a medical, educational, or financial need to exercise an unconditional withdrawal right.
This differs from a HEMS distribution, which must satisfy the applicable distribution standard.
Importantly, IRC § 2041(b)(2) establishes a special rule for the lapse of certain powers of appointment. It does not independently grant beneficiaries the right to withdraw money. That right must be created by the trust.
Can the Surviving Spouse Have a 5-and-5 Power in a QTIP Trust?
Generally, yes.
A QTIP trust can be drafted to give the surviving spouse an annual withdrawal right in addition to mandatory income distributions and permitted principal distributions.
For example, the trust might provide:
- Mandatory income distributions: The surviving spouse receives all fiduciary accounting income at least annually.
- HEMS principal distributions: The trustee may distribute principal for the spouse’s health, education, maintenance, and support.
- Annual 5-and-5 withdrawal right: The spouse may withdraw the greater of $5,000 or 5% of the trust’s value during a specified annual period.
- Remainder provisions: After the spouse dies, remaining assets pass to children or continuing trusts for their benefit.
Because the spouse’s withdrawal right is exercisable for the spouse’s own benefit, it is generally compatible with the QTIP requirement that property not be appointed to another person during the spouse’s lifetime.
The trust must still satisfy all applicable QTIP requirements.
Example: A $3 Million QTIP Trust
Assume a QTIP trust holds $3 million.
The surviving spouse receives all trust accounting income and may receive additional principal distributions under the HEMS standard.
The trust also gives the spouse an annual 5-and-5 withdrawal right.
Five percent of $3 million equals $150,000.
The spouse could therefore have the right to withdraw up to $150,000 during the applicable annual exercise period without demonstrating a qualifying HEMS expense.
If the spouse exercises the power, the withdrawn assets generally become the spouse’s own property.
If the spouse does not exercise the power, the assets ordinarily remain in the trust, subject to its terms.
What Happens When the Surviving Spouse Dies?
A QTIP trust generally terminates or changes its distribution structure when the surviving spouse dies.
The remaining property then passes according to the trust’s remainder provisions.
Rather than distributing the inheritance outright, the trust can direct that each child’s share be held in a separate continuing trust.
Each continuing trust may have its own distribution standards, trustee provisions, and withdrawal rights.
For example, a couple with three children could provide that the remaining QTIP assets are divided equally among three separate trusts.
Each child might receive:
- Discretionary distributions for health, education, maintenance, and support.
- An annual 5-and-5 withdrawal right.
- The ability to serve as trustee, subject to appropriate limitations.
- The benefit of continued trust administration and any applicable spendthrift protections.
- The ability to leave remaining assets to their descendants under the trust’s terms.
This approach can provide children with access to inherited wealth without requiring an immediate outright distribution.
Why Must the Children’s Withdrawal Powers Wait Until the Spouse Dies?
Timing is essential.
A qualifying QTIP trust generally cannot give another person a power to appoint trust property to someone other than the surviving spouse during the spouse’s lifetime.
If children could withdraw QTIP principal for themselves while the surviving spouse was alive, that authority could jeopardize the trust’s qualification for the marital deduction.
The safer structure is to provide that the children’s withdrawal powers become effective only after the surviving spouse’s death, when the property passes into their continuing trusts.
This allows the QTIP to serve its marital-deduction purpose during the spouse’s lifetime while creating a different distribution arrangement for the next generation.
Example: How a Multigenerational QTIP Plan Could Work
Assume a married couple establishes an estate plan involving a QTIP trust.
At the first spouse’s death, $3 million passes into the QTIP trust.
During the surviving spouse’s lifetime, the spouse receives trust income, may receive authorized HEMS distributions, and has a 5-and-5 withdrawal right.
Assume that $3 million remains when the surviving spouse later dies.
The trust directs the trustee to establish three separate $1 million trusts for the couple’s children.
Each child’s trust includes an annual 5-and-5 withdrawal right. With $1 million in each trust, each child could have the right to withdraw up to $50,000 per year (5% of $1 million).
These are illustrative amounts, not guaranteed annual distributions. Actual withdrawal rights depend on the trust’s wording, applicable valuation date, and available assets.
Each child could receive additional distributions if authorized under the trust’s HEMS provisions.
How Do HEMS and 5-and-5 Powers Differ?
Although the two provisions can work together, they are legally distinct.
A HEMS provision authorizes distributions for specified purposes.
A 5-and-5 provision grants a personal withdrawal right, usually without requiring the beneficiary to justify how the money will be spent.
This distinction becomes particularly important when the beneficiary also serves as trustee.
Under IRC § 2041(b)(1)(A), a power limited by an ascertainable standard relating to health, education, maintenance, or support generally is not a general power of appointment merely because the beneficiary holds it.
By contrast, an unrestricted personal withdrawal right ordinarily constitutes a general power of appointment while it is exercisable.
The special 5-and-5 lapse rule limits certain tax consequences when that power expires during the beneficiary’s lifetime.
The two provisions therefore require different tax and drafting analyses. (In California, note also that Probate Code § 16081(c) generally limits a beneficiary-trustee’s discretionary distributions to themselves to HEMS unless the trust expressly provides otherwise by reference to that subdivision.)
Does a 5-and-5 Power Create Estate-Tax Problems?
Potentially.
A common misconception is that a 5-and-5 power automatically prevents estate-tax inclusion.
That is not correct.
The federal tax rules distinguish between an active withdrawal power and a power that has lapsed.
During the Surviving Spouse’s Lifetime
Property subject to a valid QTIP election generally is included in the surviving spouse’s gross estate under IRC § 2044.
Consequently, the spouse’s 5-and-5 withdrawal power ordinarily does not eliminate that inclusion.
The QTIP property generally remains subject to the estate-inclusion rules applicable to qualified terminable interest property.
During the Children’s Lifetimes
The analysis is different for the children’s continuing trusts.
If a child holds an exercisable withdrawal right at death, the property subject to that power may be included in the child’s gross estate under IRC § 2041.
However, when an annual power lapses during the child’s lifetime, IRC § 2041(b)(2) generally prevents the lapse from being treated as a release to the extent the amount does not exceed the greater of $5,000 or 5% of the relevant assets.
Related gift-tax rules appear in IRC § 2514.
This is why a carefully drafted withdrawal period and lapse provision are important.
Can a 5-and-5 Power Help Produce a Step-Up in Basis?
Potentially, but the result requires careful analysis.
A QTIP trust may provide favorable income-tax basis treatment because property included in the surviving spouse’s gross estate under IRC § 2044 generally qualifies for the corresponding basis rules under IRC § 1014(b)(10). (See California Rental Property, Community Property, and QTIP Trusts.)
That can be particularly important for appreciated real estate and investment assets.
The children’s continuing trusts present a different issue.
If assets remain outside a child’s gross estate, those assets generally will not receive a basis adjustment at the child’s death solely because the child was a trust beneficiary.
However, property included in the child’s estate because of an exercisable general power of appointment may qualify for a basis adjustment, subject to the applicable rules.
A limited 5-and-5 power may create estate inclusion only for a relatively small portion of the trust.
It should not be assumed to create a basis adjustment for the entire continuing trust.
Estate planners must weigh the potential basis benefit against estate taxes, creditor protection, and the overall objectives of the trust.
Can Grandchildren Challenge Their Parent’s Withdrawals?
This is another important consideration in multigenerational planning. (See Can Grandchildren Sue a Parent Over Trust Distributions?)
Suppose a child receives a lifetime beneficial interest in a continuing trust, with the remainder passing to that child’s children.
The child serves as trustee and has both HEMS distribution authority and a 5-and-5 withdrawal right.
The grandchildren may believe the parent is withdrawing too much money and reducing their future inheritance.
Whether they can successfully challenge the conduct depends on the authority being exercised.
- HEMS distributions: When the parent acts as trustee, distributions must comply with the trust’s distribution standard and applicable fiduciary duties.
- 5-and-5 withdrawals: When the parent exercises a valid personal withdrawal right, the parent generally does not have to demonstrate a qualifying HEMS need.
Once property is properly withdrawn and becomes the parent’s personal property, remainder beneficiaries ordinarily cannot control how it is spent merely to preserve their anticipated inheritance.
However, grandchildren with legally recognized interests may have grounds to challenge withdrawals exceeding the trust’s limits or involving other violations of law.
Under California law, beneficiary rights and trustee duties are addressed in provisions including Probate Code § 24, § 16002, § 16003, and § 17200.
Are 5-and-5 Powers Always a Good Idea?
Not necessarily.
An annual 5% withdrawal right can provide substantial flexibility, but it can also reduce the amount of property remaining in trust.
If a beneficiary repeatedly exercises the power, trust assets may decline significantly.
Withdrawn assets also generally lose the protections associated with remaining in a properly structured trust.
For some families, a HEMS standard combined with an independent trustee’s broader discretionary distribution authority may provide a better balance.
For others, a limited annual withdrawal right may be appropriate because the trust creator wants the beneficiary to have a defined amount of financial independence.
The best approach depends on the family’s priorities.
What About Generation-Skipping Transfer Taxes?
When assets are intended to benefit children and then grandchildren, generation-skipping transfer (GST) tax planning may be important.
A QTIP election and a reverse QTIP election serve different purposes.
Under IRC § 2652(a)(3), a reverse QTIP election may permit the first spouse to remain the transferor for GST tax purposes with respect to the elected property.
This can be important when planning to use GST exemption for trusts that continue for grandchildren.
The election must be coordinated with the estate plan, the applicable GST exemption, and the trust’s intended beneficiaries.
A reverse QTIP election does not itself grant withdrawal rights or determine whether those rights are appropriate.
Important Drafting Considerations
Families considering this structure should review several issues with estate-planning counsel.
- 1. Preserve QTIP qualification. Ensure the surviving spouse receives the required income and that no prohibited third-party appointment power exists during the spouse’s lifetime.
- 2. Define the spouse’s withdrawal rights. Establish the annual amount, exercise period, valuation method, and notice procedures.
- 3. Separate the children’s interests. Consider separate continuing trusts rather than one shared trust with overlapping withdrawal rights.
- 4. Coordinate HEMS provisions. Determine whether a child serving as trustee may make self-distributions only under an ascertainable standard.
- 5. Review estate and gift taxes. Analyze active powers, annual lapses, potential releases, and estate inclusion.
- 6. Evaluate creditor protection. Determine whether withdrawal rights create additional exposure to creditors under applicable state law.
- 7. Address remainder beneficiaries. Clearly explain that authorized distributions and withdrawals may reduce the amount eventually inherited by grandchildren.
- 8. Review GST planning. Consider whether a reverse QTIP election and GST exemption allocation are appropriate.
The Bottom Line
A QTIP trust can generally be designed to provide a surviving spouse with mandatory income, HEMS principal distributions, and a limited annual 5-and-5 withdrawal right.
After the surviving spouse dies, the remaining assets can pass into separate continuing trusts that give the children their own HEMS distribution benefits and 5-and-5 withdrawal rights.
The key is ensuring that the children’s withdrawal powers do not become exercisable during the surviving spouse’s lifetime and that each generation’s rights are coordinated with the applicable estate-tax and fiduciary rules.
A properly structured multigenerational trust can provide financial flexibility for surviving spouses and children while preserving an organized inheritance plan for grandchildren.
However, 5-and-5 powers are not automatically the best choice for every family. Their benefits must be balanced against estate-tax exposure, asset protection, and the possibility of reducing the assets ultimately available to future generations.
Contact Ginsburg Law Group
Ginsburg Law Group, P.C. assists individuals and families with estate planning, trusts, and related legal matters.
If you are considering a QTIP trust, a multigenerational estate plan, or withdrawal provisions for surviving spouses and children, understanding how these provisions interact is essential.
Schedule a consultation or email estates@ginsburglawgroup.com.
Legal Authorities
- Internal Revenue Code § 2056(b)(7): Qualified Terminable Interest Property
- Internal Revenue Code § 2044: Estate Inclusion of QTIP Property
- Internal Revenue Code § 2041: Powers of Appointment
- Internal Revenue Code § 2514: Gift-Tax Treatment of Powers of Appointment
- Internal Revenue Code § 1014(b)(10): Basis of Certain QTIP Property
- Internal Revenue Code § 2652(a)(3): Reverse QTIP Election
- Treasury Regulation § 20.2056(b)-7: QTIP Requirements
- Treasury Regulation § 20.2041-3: Powers of Appointment and Lapses
- California Probate Code §§ 24, 16002, 16003, and 17200
Disclaimer: This article provides general educational information and does not constitute individualized legal or tax advice. The effectiveness of QTIP trusts, withdrawal powers, and multigenerational estate-planning strategies depends on the trust instrument, tax elections, applicable federal and state law, and individual circumstances. Reading this article does not establish an attorney-client relationship with Ginsburg Law Group, P.C.


