Lemon Law

Lemon Law Myth-Busting: “If It Still Drives, It’s Not a Lemon” (Not True)

A car doesn’t have to be completely undrivable to qualify for lemon law or breach of warranty options. What matters is the pattern of problems, repair attempts, and documentation.

Myth: “If the car runs, you’re stuck with it.”

Reality: Many claims involve vehicles that technically drive—but have recurring defects, safety issues, or repeated repair visits.

What matters most: repair attempts and records

If you’re dealing with repeated issues, your paperwork is your power. Save:

  • Repair orders (every visit)
  • Dealer notes and diagnostics
  • Warranty documents
  • Tow receipts (if any)
  • Photos/videos of the defect when it happens

A common rule of thumb (fact-specific)

Many strong cases involve:

  • 3+ repair visits for the same issue, or
  • Significant time out of service

Exact standards vary by state and situation.

Mistakes that can weaken a claim

  • Not getting a repair order every time
  • Waiting too long to return for the same issue
  • Fixing it “off the books” without documentation

What outcomes can look like

Depending on the facts and the manufacturer, outcomes may include:

  • Repurchase/buyback
  • Replacement
  • Cash settlement

No outcome is guaranteed—your facts, documents, and state law matter.

Think your vehicle may qualify? If your car has been in 3+ times for the same issue, contact Ginsburg Law Group, PC for a case review.

Related Posts