Odometer Rollback

GET YOUR FREE CONSULTATION
CALL NOW:855-978-6564
Practice Areas
Free Case Evaluation

Fill out the form below for a free, confidential case evaluation and we will contact you shortly. All fields are required.

    Full Name*

    Email*

    Phone*

    Describe your case briefly

    Odometer Rollback Fraud Cases

    An odometer should be one of the most reliable indicators of a vehicle’s value. But dishonest sellers and dealers sometimes engage in odometer rollback fraud — tampering with a vehicle’s mileage to make it appear less used than it really is. This practice is illegal under both federal law (49 U.S.C. Chapter 327) and state consumer protection statutes.

    How to Spot Odometer Rollback

    Signs that your car’s mileage may have been altered:

    • The wear and tear (steering wheel, seats, pedals, tires) doesn’t match the displayed mileage.

    • The odometer numbers don’t line up correctly or look tampered with (on mechanical odometers).

    • Inconsistent records between the title, Carfax/AutoCheck, or DMV history.

    • Service stickers (oil change, maintenance) show higher mileage than the odometer.

    • The vehicle title is marked “exempt” or “not actual mileage.”

    🚩 Red flag: If the car looks older than its mileage suggests, or if reports conflict, odometer fraud may be at play.

    How to Avoid Odometer Fraud

    • Check Carfax/AutoCheck: Always request a vehicle history report before buying.

    • Ask for Maintenance Records: Compare reported mileage with service receipts.

    • Inspect for Wear: Look at the interior and mechanical parts — they tell the real story.

    • Verify with DMV: Many states allow you to check title and odometer history.

    • Get a Pre-Purchase Inspection: Mechanics can often spot signs of tampering.

    Why Dealers or Sellers Hide Mileage

    Dealers may roll back or misreport odometers to:

    • Inflate the car’s value — low mileage vehicles sell for more.

    • Avoid warranty limits — mileage can affect manufacturer coverage.

    • Disguise prior use — such as rentals, fleet cars, or high-mileage lease returns.

    Common Defenses Dealers Raise

    When caught, dealers often argue:

    • “The odometer broke and was replaced.”

    • “We didn’t know — we sold it as is.”

    • “The discrepancy was a clerical/title error.”

    An attorney can push past these defenses by obtaining dealer service records, auction documents, and DMV filings to show knowledge of the fraud.

    Types of Odometer Fraud Cases

    • Mechanical rollback: Manual tampering on older analog odometers.

    • Digital rollback: Using software tools to alter electronic odometers.

    • Cluster swapping: Replacing the entire instrument cluster with one showing lower mileage.

    • Title washing: Transferring a title across states to remove mileage disclosures.

    • Failure to disclose “true mileage unknown” (TMU): Selling a car without noting mileage discrepancies on the title.

    Potential Legal Claims

    Victims of odometer fraud may have claims for:

    • Federal Odometer Act violations (civil liability under 49 U.S.C. § 32710)

    • State consumer fraud/UDAP statutes

    • Common law fraud and misrepresentation

    • Breach of warranty or contract (if mileage impacted warranty eligibility)

    Potential Damages

    Successful odometer rollback cases may allow recovery of:

    • Three times actual damages under federal law (treble damages)

    • Rescission of the deal (cancel contract, refund purchase price, return trade-in value)

    • Diminished value damages

    • Attorney’s fees and costs

    • Punitive damages (in some states for intentional fraud)

    Why Hire an Attorney

    Odometer rollback is serious fraud, but it can be difficult to prove without legal help. An experienced attorney can:

    • Trace title and mileage history through DMV and NMVTIS databases

    • Subpoena auction and dealer records

    • Work with experts to identify tampering

    • Pursue treble damages and attorney’s fees under federal law

    Suspect Odometer Fraud?

    If you believe your car’s mileage has been tampered with or misrepresented, you may have a strong legal claim.

    Common Fact Patterns in Odometer Rollback Cases

    Odometer fraud usually follows predictable patterns. Spotting these fact patterns can help prove your case:

    1. The “Auction Rollback”

    • A high-mileage car is sold at auction.

    • Before resale, the odometer is rolled back to make the car more marketable.

    • The dealership lists the vehicle as “low mileage” when reselling it to consumers.

    🚩 Red flag: Carfax/AutoCheck often show mileage discrepancies between auction and retail sale.

    2. The “Fleet or Rental Car Disguise”

    • Fleet cars and rentals rack up thousands of miles quickly.

    • Before being sold as “used,” the odometer is tampered with or the title is “washed.”

    • Buyer believes they’re getting a gently used car when it’s really been heavily driven.

    🚩 Red flag: Service records reveal far higher mileage than what’s on the dash.

    3. The “Cluster Swap”

    • A dealership or seller swaps out the entire instrument cluster with one from a lower-mileage car.

    • The mileage on the dash no longer matches the car’s true history.

    • Unless disclosed, this is clear odometer fraud.

    🚩 Red flag: Title may be marked “not actual mileage” or “exempt,” but consumer was never told.

    4. The “Title Washing”

    • A car with a branded title (e.g., “true mileage unknown”) is transferred across state lines.

    • The new state issues a clean title without mileage disclosures.

    • Dealer resells the vehicle as if nothing is wrong.

    🚩 Red flag: Different states showing different mileage histories.

    5. The “Service Record Conflict”

    • Dealer claims the vehicle has, for example, 40,000 miles.

    • Service stickers, oil change records, or DMV inspections show the car had 60,000 miles years earlier.

    • The paperwork contradicts the odometer reading.

    🚩 Red flag: Any inconsistency between service paperwork and current mileage.

    6. The “Warranty Cut-Off” Scheme

    • Mileage tampering is used to keep a car under warranty limits (e.g., under 36,000 miles).

    • Consumer buys the car believing it’s still covered.

    • Later, warranty claims are denied because manufacturer discovers the true mileage.

    🚩 Red flag: Warranty denied for “mileage inconsistency” — a major sign of rollback.

    Why These Patterns Matter

    Courts and regulators recognize these recurring scams. By showing that your case matches a known pattern, an attorney can:

    • Strengthen your fraud and misrepresentation claims

    • Pursue treble damages under federal odometer laws

    • Demand rescission or refunds of the fraudulent deal

    • Seek attorney’s fees and punitive damages