Lemon Law Resources
Where to Find Information for Your Lemon Law Claim
Building a strong Lemon Law case starts with solid documentation. The more proof you have about your vehicle’s defect, repair history, and the manufacturer’s knowledge of the issue, the stronger your claim will be.
Here’s where to look:
1. Vehicle Defect & Complaint Databases
National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) – Complaints & Recalls
-
Website: https://www.nhtsa.gov/recalls
-
Search by your VIN or vehicle year/make/model to see:
-
Recalls
-
Technical service bulletins (TSBs)
-
Consumer complaints
-
-
Useful to show pattern of defects.
SaferCar.gov
-
Website: https://www.safercar.gov/
-
NHTSA’s consumer portal — also offers a VIN Lookup Tool and mobile app.
CarComplaints.com
-
Website: https://www.carcomplaints.com/
-
Tracks owner-submitted complaints by year, make, and model.
Edmunds & Kelley Blue Book Forums
-
Websites: https://www.edmunds.com/forums/ | https://www.kbb.com/car-news/all-the-latest/
-
Discussions often reveal widespread, unpublicized problems.
2. Manufacturer Resources
Warranty Booklet / Owner’s Manual
-
Typically found in your glove box or on the manufacturer’s website.
-
Shows:
-
Length of warranty
-
Covered systems/components
-
Required maintenance schedules
-
-
Proves the defect is within warranty coverage.
Technical Service Bulletins (TSBs)
-
Manufacturer-issued instructions to dealers on known defects and repair procedures.
-
Can be found through:
-
NHTSA’s website
-
Paid services like ALLDATA (https://www.alldata.com/)
-
Sometimes available free through manufacturer websites
-
3. Your Repair & Purchase Records
Dealer Repair Orders
-
Each visit should generate a repair order detailing:
-
Date
-
Mileage
-
Complaint
-
Technician’s diagnosis
-
Repair performed
-
-
Crucial for proving repair attempts.
Purchase/Lease Agreement
-
Shows:
-
Purchase price
-
Delivery date (starts the Lemon Law clock)
-
VIN
-
-
Often required to calculate buyback amounts.
Service History Printout
-
Ask your dealer for a full service history — sometimes it shows internal notes and prior repairs you weren’t told about.
4. Recall Information
Manufacturer Recall Pages
-
Search your VIN directly on your car maker’s recall site (e.g., Toyota, Ford, Honda all have recall search pages).
-
Useful if your defect is related to a known recall.
5. Vehicle History Reports
Carfax & AutoCheck
-
May reveal:
-
Warranty claims filed by previous owners
-
Prior accidents that could affect defect coverage
-
-
Note: Prior damage could impact eligibility, so review carefully.
6. Other Helpful Sources
-
State DMV Websites – Some states post consumer alerts about recurring defects.
-
Online Owner Groups – Facebook groups, Reddit forums, and brand-specific clubs can be goldmines for finding other owners with the same issue.
-
Lemon Law Attorneys’ Blogs – Many publish updates about recalls, TSBs, and defect trends.
Tip for Building Your Case
-
Organize evidence chronologically — purchase docs first, then repair orders, then correspondence.
-
Keep digital scans so they can be easily shared with your attorney.
-
The more you can show the defect is widespread and unresolved, the more leverage you have in negotiations.
Car Parts Payment & Common Issues Guide
Understanding which car parts fail most often, how much they cost to repair, and who should pay (you or the manufacturer) can help you make smart repair decisions and protect your warranty rights.
1. How Payment Responsibility Works
Situation | Who Usually Pays | Notes |
---|---|---|
Under Manufacturer’s New Car Warranty | Manufacturer | Covers defects in materials/workmanship; excludes wear items like brake pads & tires unless defective |
Under Extended Warranty/Service Contract | Warranty Company | Coverage depends on contract terms; may require deductibles |
Under Recall | Manufacturer | Repairs are free — even if warranty expired |
Under Technical Service Bulletin (TSB) | Manufacturer (sometimes) | TSBs are not recalls; coverage depends on warranty status |
Normal Wear & Tear | Owner | Items like brake pads, wiper blades, tires unless proven defective |
Accident Damage | Insurance | Subject to deductible and policy coverage |
2. Common Car Parts & Repair Costs
(Average retail repair cost ranges; actual costs vary by make/model)
Part / System | Common Issues | Typical Cost | Covered by Warranty? |
---|---|---|---|
Engine | Oil leaks, overheating, misfires, timing chain issues | $1,500 – $6,000 | Yes, if defect & within warranty |
Transmission | Slipping, hard shifts, fluid leaks | $2,500 – $5,500 | Yes, if defect & within warranty |
Brakes | Squealing, pulsation, reduced stopping power | Pads $150–$300 per axle; Rotors $250–$500 | Wear items unless defective |
Suspension/Shocks | Clunking, uneven tire wear, poor ride quality | $500 – $1,500 | Yes, if premature failure under warranty |
Electrical System | Dead battery, faulty alternator, wiring shorts | Battery $150–$300; Alternator $400–$900 | Battery often prorated; alternator covered |
Air Conditioning | Not cooling, strange noises, refrigerant leaks | $200 – $1,500 | Covered if under warranty |
Fuel System | Fuel pump failure, clogged injectors | $400 – $1,200 | Yes, if defect-related |
Steering | Power steering leaks, rack & pinion failure | $500 – $1,800 | Yes, if defect & under warranty |
Cooling System | Radiator leaks, water pump failure | $300 – $1,000 | Yes, if defect-related |
Exhaust System | Muffler rust, catalytic converter failure | Muffler $200–$600; Converter $900–$2,500 | Catalytic converters often covered longer under federal emissions warranty |
3. Common Manufacturer Defect Patterns
Knowing these can help you argue warranty coverage instead of paying out of pocket:
-
Oil Consumption – Certain makes/models have chronic oil burning issues.
-
Transmission Failures – CVT transmissions in some Nissan, Honda, and Ford models have known defect histories.
-
Timing Chain Tensioners – Premature wear on certain BMW, Mini, and VW engines.
-
Infotainment Failures – Screens freezing or rebooting in Ford Sync, Honda Link, and Chrysler Uconnect systems.
-
Water Leaks – Sunroof drains or door seals on certain SUVs.
4. Tips to Avoid Paying for Covered Repairs
-
Always ask if there’s a recall or TSB for your issue before paying.
-
Document symptoms early — even if the dealer can’t reproduce them, it puts the defect on record.
-
Push for warranty coverage if the failure is abnormal for the mileage.
-
Keep all receipts for repairs — may be reimbursed later if a recall is issued.
5. When to Call a Lemon Law Attorney
-
The same part/system fails multiple times under warranty.
-
Your vehicle is out of service for 30+ days for repairs.
-
Manufacturer refuses to cover a clear defect within warranty.
-
Major system (engine, transmission, electrical) fails early in ownership.