Debt Defense – Pennsylvania Procedure

GET YOUR FREE CONSULTATION
CALL NOW:855-978-6564
Practice Areas
Free Case Evaluation

Fill out the form below for a free, confidential case evaluation and we will contact you shortly. All fields are required.

    Full Name*

    Email*

    Phone*

    Describe your case briefly

    How Consumer Debt Cases Move Through the Pennsylvania Court System

    If you’ve been sued for credit card debt, a personal loan, a medical bill, or a private student loan in Pennsylvania, your case will follow a structured process.

    Knowing how debt claims move through PA courts — and when you must respond — can help you protect your rights and possibly defeat or settle the case.

    1. Pennsylvania Court Structure for Debt Cases

    Most consumer debt lawsuits in PA are filed in:

    • Magisterial District Court (MDJ)

      • Handles civil cases up to $12,000 (excluding interest and costs)

      • Informal; no jury trials — a district judge hears the case

      • Designed for faster resolution and lower costs

    • Court of Common Pleas

      • Handles civil claims over $12,000

      • More formal process, full discovery allowed

      • Jury trials available

      • Also hears appeals from MDJ

    2. How a Debt Lawsuit Begins in Pennsylvania

    A. Filing the Complaint

    • In MDJ, the creditor files a Civil Complaint with a hearing date set by the court.

    • In Common Pleas, the creditor files either:

      • A Complaint (formal legal pleading), or

      • A Writ of Summons (short notice to start the case; full complaint filed later)

    B. Service of Process

    • Must be served by the court, sheriff, or certified mail (depending on the court).

    • Service rules are strict — improper service can be a defense.

    3. Time to Respond

    • Magisterial District Court:

      • The hearing date is usually set 2–4 weeks after filing.

      • No formal written answer is required — you must appear on the hearing date with your evidence.

      • If you don’t appear, the court will likely issue a default judgment.

    • Court of Common Pleas:

      • You generally have 20 days to respond to a Complaint.

      • If you don’t respond, you’ll receive a 10-day notice before the creditor can seek a default judgment.

      • Failing to respond after that results in judgment against you.

    4. Pre-Hearing or Pretrial Stage

    • MDJ:

      • No discovery; bring all documents and witnesses to the hearing.

      • Judge may encourage settlement before taking testimony.

    • Common Pleas:

      • Full pretrial process: pleadings, discovery, motions, possible settlement conferences.

    5. Discovery (Evidence Exchange)

    • MDJ: None — all evidence must be presented at the hearing.

    • Common Pleas: Parties can send interrogatories, request documents, and take depositions.

    6. The Hearing or Trial

    • MDJ:

      • Informal, usually lasts less than an hour.

      • Judge decides based on testimony and documents.

      • Decision is typically issued the same day or shortly after.

    • Common Pleas:

      • Can be bench trial (judge) or jury trial.

      • Follows formal Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure and Rules of Evidence.

    The creditor must prove:

    1. They own the debt (especially important in debt buyer cases)

    2. You agreed to the debt (contract or account)

    3. The amount claimed is accurate

    7. Judgment

    If the creditor wins, the court enters judgment for:

    • Principal balance

    • Interest

    • Court costs

    • Attorney’s fees (if allowed by contract or statute)

    Judgments in PA are valid for 5 years, renewable for additional 5-year periods.

    8. Post-Judgment Collections in Pennsylvania

    A creditor with a judgment can:

    • Garnish bank accounts (wages are generally not garnished for most consumer debts in PA — an important protection)

    • Place a lien on real property

    • Seize certain personal property (rare in consumer debt cases)

    9. Appeals

    • From MDJ to Common Pleas:

      • You have 30 days from the judgment date to file an appeal.

      • The case starts over (“de novo”) in Common Pleas.

      • You may need to post an appeal bond for certain cases.

    10. Common Defenses and Violations

    • Statute of Limitations – In PA, most written contracts have a 4-year limit from default/last payment.

    • Lack of Standing – Debt buyer cannot prove legal ownership of the account.

    • Improper Service – Failure to serve according to PA rules.

    • FCRA / FDCPA Violations – False credit reporting or abusive debt collection practices.

    Key Takeaways

    • PA has strong wage protection — wages can’t be garnished for most consumer debts.

    • Respond promptly — missing deadlines in Common Pleas or not showing up in MDJ can lead to fast judgments.

    • Even if you owe the debt, you can often negotiate a settlement or payment plan.

    • Debt buyers often lack the paperwork needed to prove their case — challenge their evidence.

    📞 Facing a debt lawsuit in Pennsylvania?
    We defend consumers across Pennsylvania in both Magisterial District Court and Court of Common Pleas, and we fight to protect your bank accounts and property from improper collection. Call 855-978-6564!