Bankruptcy

Free Consultation Available

GET YOUR FREE CONSULTATION
CALL NOW:855-978-6564
Practice Areas
Free Case Evaluation

Fill out the form below for a free, confidential case evaluation and we will contact you shortly. All fields are required.

    Full Name*

    Email*

    Phone*

    Describe your case briefly

    How Student Loans Can Be Discharged in Bankruptcy

    Many people are told that student loans can never be discharged in bankruptcy. That is not true. While student loans are not automatically discharged, federal law allows them to be discharged when a borrower can prove undue hardship through a specific legal process.

    This page explains how student loan discharge works, what is required, and when bankruptcy may — or may not — be the right path.

    The General Rule: Student Loans Are Not Automatically Discharged

    Unlike credit cards or medical bills, most student loans do not disappear automatically at the end of a bankruptcy case. This includes:

    • Federal student loans

    • Most private student loans

    • Loans guaranteed by governmental or nonprofit entities

    Instead, borrowers must take extra legal steps and meet a strict legal standard to obtain discharge.

    The Legal Standard: “Undue Hardship”

    To discharge student loans, a borrower must prove that repayment would cause undue hardship. This is a legal term defined by federal court decisions — not by financial discomfort alone.

    Most courts, including those in Pennsylvania, apply a test known as the Brunner Test.

    The Brunner Test Explained (Plain English)

    To qualify for student loan discharge, the borrower must prove all three of the following:

    1. You Cannot Maintain a Minimal Standard of Living if Forced to Repay

    The court looks at:

    • Income

    • Necessary living expenses

    • Dependents

    • Medical or disability-related costs

    This does not require poverty, but it does require proof that repayment would prevent you from meeting basic needs such as housing, food, utilities, and healthcare.

    2. Your Financial Hardship Is Likely to Continue

    The court examines whether your financial situation is unlikely to improve for a significant portion of the repayment period.

    Factors may include:

    • Chronic illness or disability

    • Advanced age

    • Limited employment prospects

    • Long-term caregiving responsibilities

    Temporary setbacks usually do not qualify.

    3. You Have Made a Good-Faith Effort to Repay

    Courts consider whether you have:

    • Made payments when possible

    • Attempted income-driven repayment plans

    • Communicated with loan servicers

    • Avoided intentionally defaulting

    This does not require perfect repayment history — but it does require honest effort.

    The Legal Process: Adversary Proceedings

    Student loan discharge is not automatic. It requires filing a separate lawsuit within the bankruptcy case, called an adversary proceeding.

    What Is an Adversary Proceeding?

    An adversary proceeding is a formal lawsuit filed in bankruptcy court against:

    • The U.S. Department of Education (for federal loans), or

    • The private lender or loan holder

    The borrower must present evidence, testimony, and legal arguments to support undue hardship.

    What Evidence Is Typically Required?

    Evidence may include:

    • Income records and tax returns

    • Medical records or disability documentation

    • Employment history

    • Household expense breakdowns

    • Repayment history

    • Loan balance and interest history

    Each case is highly fact-specific.

    Partial Discharge or Modified Relief

    In some cases, courts may:

    • Discharge part of the student loan balance

    • Discharge interest but not principal

    • Approve repayment modifications

    While not guaranteed, partial relief is possible in certain circumstances.

    Federal vs. Private Student Loans

    Federal Student Loans

    Federal loans are subject to the undue hardship standard but may also be influenced by:

    • Income-driven repayment eligibility

    • Administrative policies

    • Settlement discretion by the Department of Education

    Recent policy changes have made it somewhat easier for qualifying borrowers to resolve undue hardship cases through negotiated outcomes, though discharge is still not automatic.

    Private Student Loans

    Private loans may:

    • Still require undue hardship proof

    • Be challenged if improperly classified

    • Be subject to consumer protection defenses

    Some private loans do not meet the legal definition required for nondischargeability, depending on how they were structured.

    Timing: When Can You Seek Discharge?

    A borrower may seek student loan discharge:

    • During a Chapter 7 case

    • During or after a Chapter 13 case

    Some borrowers pursue discharge after completing Chapter 13, once a long-term inability to repay is clearer.

    Why Most Borrowers Are Told “It’s Impossible”

    Student loan discharge cases are:

    • Complex

    • Evidence-intensive

    • Time-consuming

    • Often misunderstood

    As a result, many attorneys simply tell clients it cannot be done — even when legally possible.

    When Bankruptcy Still Makes Sense Even Without Discharge

    Even if discharge is unlikely, bankruptcy may still help by:

    • Eliminating other debt

    • Stopping wage garnishment

    • Halting lawsuits

    • Improving long-term affordability

    For many borrowers, bankruptcy is a strategic tool, not just a discharge mechanism.

    Important Misconceptions

    “Student loans are never dischargeable.”
    False. They are difficult — not impossible — to discharge.

    “I need to be totally disabled.”
    Not always. Courts look at long-term hardship, not just disability status.

    “Trying and failing will hurt me.”
    Simply seeking discharge does not penalize borrowers.

    Should You Explore Student Loan Discharge?

    Student loan discharge is not right for everyone, but it may be appropriate if you:

    • Have long-term financial hardship

    • Have medical or disability-related limitations

    • Are nearing retirement age

    • Have exhausted repayment options

    A careful legal review is essential.

    When Student Loan Discharge Is Unlikely in Bankruptcy

    Many borrowers ask whether bankruptcy will eliminate their student loans. While student loan discharge is legally possible, it is not common, and there are situations where discharge is unlikely based on how bankruptcy courts apply the law.

    This page explains when student loan discharge is usually not successful, and what options may still be available.

    Why Student Loan Discharge Is Hard to Obtain

    Student loans are treated differently from most other debts because federal law requires borrowers to prove undue hardship. Courts apply a strict legal standard, and many borrowers simply do not meet that standard — even when they are struggling financially.

    Discharge is not based on debt size alone or on how unfair the loan feels.

    Situations Where Discharge Is Often Unlikely

    1. You Have Stable or Increasing Income

    If you:

    • Are currently employed

    • Have stable earnings

    • Are likely to earn more in the future

    Courts often conclude that repayment hardship is temporary, even if payments are difficult right now.

    2. You Qualify for Income-Driven Repayment Plans

    Courts frequently consider whether a borrower is eligible for:

    • Income-Driven Repayment (IDR)

    • Income-Based Repayment (IBR)

    • Pay As You Earn (PAYE)

    • Other government repayment programs

    If your monthly payment could be reduced to a manageable level through these programs, courts may find that undue hardship does not exist, even if you disagree with the long-term consequences.

    3. Your Financial Difficulties Are Temporary

    Discharge is less likely if your hardship is due to:

    • Short-term unemployment

    • Recent divorce

    • Temporary medical issues

    • Recent business failure

    Courts focus on long-term inability, not short-term financial distress.

    4. You Have Not Attempted Repayment or Relief Programs

    Courts look closely at whether borrowers have made a good-faith effort to repay.

    Discharge is less likely if you:

    • Never made payments

    • Immediately defaulted after graduation

    • Did not explore repayment options

    • Ignored loan servicer communications

    Good faith does not require perfect payment history — but it does require effort.

    5. Your Loans Are Relatively New

    Borrowers with recently issued student loans may have difficulty proving that:

    • Their hardship will persist

    • Future earning potential is limited

    Long-term repayment history often matters.

    6. You Are Healthy and of Working Age

    If you:

    • Are physically able to work

    • Have no documented disabilities

    • Are relatively early in your career

    Courts may assume future earning potential, even if current income is modest.

    Common Misunderstandings That Lead to False Expectations

    “My loan balance is enormous — it should qualify.”
    Loan size alone does not determine discharge eligibility.

    “I can’t afford payments right now.”
    Temporary inability does not meet the undue hardship standard.

    “I’m emotionally overwhelmed.”
    Courts require financial and factual evidence, not stress alone.

    When Bankruptcy Still Makes Sense Without Discharge

    Even when discharge is unlikely, bankruptcy may still help by:

    • Eliminating other debt so student loan payments become manageable

    • Stopping wage garnishments and lawsuits

    • Creating financial breathing room

    • Improving long-term stability

    For many borrowers, bankruptcy is a strategic reset, not a student loan eraser.

    Alternative Relief Options to Consider

    If discharge is unlikely, borrowers may still benefit from:

    • Income-Driven Repayment plans

    • Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF)

    • Repayment Assistance Programs

    • Loan consolidation

    • Consumer protection claims for servicing errors

    • Bankruptcy to eliminate other debt

    A careful review helps determine which combination of options makes sense.

    Why Many Borrowers Are Still Told “Bankruptcy Won’t Help”

    Student loan cases require:

    • Additional litigation

    • Evidence gathering

    • Legal analysis

    • Cost-benefit evaluation

    Some attorneys avoid these cases entirely, even when partial relief or indirect benefits exist.

    Should You Still Talk to a Lawyer?

    Yes. Even when discharge is unlikely, a lawyer can:

    • Evaluate all legal options

    • Identify servicing or classification issues

    • Recommend strategic timing

    • Prevent costly mistakes

    Understanding your position early can save years of unnecessary hardship.

    Speak With a Lawyer About Student Loan Discharge

    If student loans are preventing you from achieving financial stability, you deserve accurate information — not myths.

    Ginsburg Law Group helps clients understand when student loan discharge may be possible and when other strategies make more sense.

    📞 Call us today for a free, confidential bankruptcy consultation – 855-978-6564 or email us at bankruptcy@ginsburglawgroup.com.

    CLICK HERE for your free case assessment.

    Contact our Bankruptcy Team: bankruptcy@ginsburglawgroup.com

    We work with most major legal services and legal insurance plans.  Some cover your legal fees for bankruptcy services.  Give us a call today to see if your bankruptcy is covered!

    BANKRUPTCY TEAM

    AMY GINSBURG – aginsburg@ginsburglawgroup.com

    GRACIE KLEIN – gklein@ginsburglawgroup.com

    NICOLE LOMBARDI – nlombardi@ginsburglawgroup.com